How to radically regulate CO2 emissions?
You would think that materials cost more when it takes more energy to make them, but this isn’t necessarily the case. In practice, installing a steel beam may cost less than a wooden beam; a cement-based screed costs less than a rammed earth floor, and rockwool costs less than wood-fibre insulation. There are a few key reasons for this: for one, the market for current materials is larger contributing to economies of scale; less energy-consuming materials may be more labor-intensive, and products like concrete and steel are risk-averse. Industrial materials last a long time and perform in a predictable manner.
That’s ideal for a building, but not so ideal for the world. Given the choice, it is understandable that clients would choose the safer option. This benefits the client themself, while it pushes the external negative effects of the decision to society at large. Clients continue to emit CO2, while we all face the consequences through droughts, sea level rise, and heat waves. Architects may feel trapped in the industry: willing to change, but unable to follow through on ideals. Smaller projects may allow for more experimentation, as unexpected issues are less impactful. While such projects can inspire others to follow, their positive impact is also limited.
How to radically regulate CO2 emissions?
For the Fashion Farm of Joline Jolink, we volunteered to build a rammed earth floor with the help of experts and other volunteers. Our goal: to prevent yet another cement screed on the ground floor.
At some point we may have to look for incentives to do the right thing, using both a stick and a carrot: a stick to make sure the polluter pays the price, and a carrot to make positive projects financially viable. Typically a society regulates this through taxes and subsidies, but we think there are other solutions that may be more effective.
In our experience, the perceived risk associated with biobased and geobased innovations is one of the deciding factors. Costs go up when a solution is deemed risky. For example: without proper experience with the material, a contractor will be hesitant to guarantee the quality of a rammed earth floor. Consequently, the price for such would go up, making the floor costly compared to a typical cement screed. As society benefits from a loam floor instead of a cement one, could society not also cover the associated risk?
How to radically regulate CO2 emissions?
For project Dijkhuis we first used wooden foundation piles. Intrigued by the possibilities of wooden foundations, we continued to research the topic and made a documentary about our adventure.
We would like to propose a public insurance for those building solutions that save a radical amount of CO2 emissions. No subsidies need to be given. It doesn’t cost society a single dime to get started. All it does is offer support when something unexpected happens. For example: if an architect proposes wooden foundation piles as a way to store CO2 and to build on, we could compare the savings to a typical concrete foundation. Every ton of CO2 saved is worth a certain amount of money. If anything unexpected happens, the project can tap into this amount as insurance to mitigate problems along the way. In an ideal situation, no repairs need to be covered as the risk of a particular application may rather be a question of perception.
Such a solution would stimulate experiment: do the right thing and we got you covered!
Can we build on wooden foundation piles?
Is there a future for prismatic glass?
What kind of work does la-di-da do?
What’s the point of this website?
close article (x)